BEREA, KY – If you’re searching for the best Berea KY dinner theater experience, look no further than The Spotlight Playhouse. This December, the Playhouse was alive with holiday spirit as the Bluegrass Players brought “A Merry Mishap” to the stage—a brand-new Christmas dinner show Berea residents will remember for years to come. Directed and written by Chad Hembree, this sold-out event was a milestone for both the Playhouse and the local community.
Why No Christmas Carol This Year?
In November, the talented youth of Spotlight Acting School performed “A Christmas Carol,” allowing young actors the rare chance to play classic roles like Scrooge. Because the kids took on this holiday tradition, the Bluegrass Players presented something original for the December dinner theater—making way for “A Merry Mishap” at the Spotlight Playhouse.
A Fresh Format and Interactive Fun
This was the first time the Christmas showcase was produced as a dinner show in Berea, KY. Lee’s Catering provided a full turkey dinner with all the trimmings, earning rave reviews from guests. Over 40 actors—including grandparents, parents, and children—participated, making the event truly intergenerational. Audiences enjoyed a delicious meal and an immersive, interactive mystery, cementing The Spotlight Playhouse as a leader in Berea KY dinner theater.
The Plot and Audience Engagement
In “A Merry Mishap,” a fundraising chest goes missing, and the audience is drawn into the fun as suspects and clues pile up. The stage manager and PTA president’s frantic interruptions kept everyone guessing, and several guests correctly solved the Christmas dinner show’s central mystery. Their prize? Tickets to the next dinner show, “The Tomb,” coming February 13–15, 2026—a murder mystery set in 1999 Egypt, where romance, danger, and interactive sleuthing await at The Spotlight Playhouse.
Spotlight on Friendship and Tradition
A crowd favorite was Jeremy Grant, director at Madison Southern High School, who reprised his beloved role as Billy Ray—a character that’s been part of the Bluegrass Players’ showcase since 2014. Jeremy and Chad Hembree’s decades-long friendship shone through their on-stage camaraderie, adding warmth and humor to this Berea KY dinner theater tradition. The twist? Billy Ray tried to double the fundraiser money through cryptocurrency—delighting the crowd with a modern, playful punchline.
What’s Next for the Christmas Dinner Show in Berea?
While “A Merry Mishap” won’t return next year, plans are in the works to bring the Christmas showcase back in two or three years—potentially as another dinner show if the youth reprise “A Christmas Carol.” The Spotlight Playhouse continues to set the standard for Berea KY dinner theater and family-friendly entertainment.
As the Playhouse takes a well-deserved two-week break, we wish everyone a Merry Christmas, a Happy New Year, and God’s blessings. Thank you to the cast, crew, and community for making this event such a memorable success!

